News media outlets have become a platform where society sources information. This information is mediated to us through text, video and imagery. News reports mediate information to their viewers through preferred meaning. Every text that has been mediated to us is decoded, constructed and delivered as an intended message. This preferred meaning has an effect on how society shapes their opinion on topics of discussion. The perception of what we choose to believe from the information that is given creates the reality. However, it is the viewers’ choice whether they decide to engage with the news or not. In this essay, I will discuss an analytical comparison of the news report on the Westminster attack that occurred on March 22, 2017. Within this analysis, I am required to source the news report from two news broadcasters within the same jurisdiction, one from a commercial broadcaster and one from a Public Service Broadcaster. I must refer to theories that we studied within this semester while focusing on the question at hand; Can the news media continue to act as producers of meaning whilst remaining within the structure of formal rules about impartiality?.
This comparative analysis investigates how Sky news and BBC News create media content while remaining under the accord of the 2009 Broadcasting Act with regard to impartiality. The Broadcasting Authority of the United Kingdom Ofcom Broadcasting Code reports that “News, in whatever form, must be reported with due accuracy and presented with due impartiality” (Ofcom, 2017). Sky and BBC News operate under United Kingdom broadcasting regulations (Sky news, 2017) (Bbc.co.uk, 2017). Following, Watershed regulations BBC and Sky news reports were reported between the hours of 21:00-5:30 due to the explicit footage (Watershed (broadcasting), 2017).
On the 22nd of March, 2017 an attack occurred in the Palace of Westminster Abbey in London. It was reported that four people were fatally injured, whilst 46 people were injured. While news outlets reported it was a terrorist attack it was later confirmed by police that no link was associated with the attacker and a terrorist organisation (2017 Westminster attack, 2017). While the BBC is a public broadcaster and Sky news is a commercial broadcaster, both news stations deliver the news in a very different manner. As BBC news is funded by the British Government and Sky news is a private limited company (Sky news, 2017) (BBC,2017). Sky news is much more dependable on grabbing the audiences’ attention by reporting sooner on news reports relying on ratings and views. However, Sky facts which are reported may not always be confirmed prior to the report (Cushion, Lewis and Lang, 2010). This inaccuracy that is reported to the viewer demonstrates the broadcasters intention of the preferred meaning without confirming references first. While both news outlets reported on the same report I was quite surprised how BBC reported the incident. The use of the first witness still in shock from the scene perceived BBC as insensitive with the reporter asking “how many bodies did you see” to the Danish student.
Boorstin (1961) states that reports by news outlets can be categorised into three events. These include Genuine Events, Media Events and Pseudo-Events. The Westminster attack is classified as a Genuine event as it occurred without the production of the media. However, this event became a mediated event through the construction of reality. The use of live and recorded footage placed in the report gives viewers the illusion of what is reality. The created fabrication of this Genuine event formed into a media event holds the viewers’ attention for the purpose of entertainment. This information which is mediated to us is second-hand information. Only witnesses who witnessed the scene obtain first-hand information. Sky news re-presentation of the information is that this attack was an attack on terrorism. The use of the sidebar coming across the screen displaying “Terror Attack” identifies the preferred meaning which Sky news communicates to its audience. However, BBC does not indicate a bias throughout the report. Although, during one of the interviews with Ismail, the reporter questions the Ismail about the identification of the driver trying to construct the viewer’s thoughts that it was a terrorist attack asking “Did you get a chance to see the gentleman driving the car”. This perception of what we believe from the information that is given creates the reality. Certain news may be seen to some viewers as informative and to others as fear mongering. Information becomes more newsworthy when it affects people.
As the discourse of fear pervades everyday life, more experiences seem to be captured by it. Audiences then become more likely to be included as corroborating witnesses to give testimony compatible with the themes resonating the discourse of fear (Altheide, 1997, p. 19).
This report is based on fear. The opening scene of the BBC report displays live footage of civilians running in panic while the background audio plays several screams and gunshots. The intention of the beginning of this report captures the viewers’ attention combining with the increase in the audio volume with the screams and sounds of gun shots. Following the next scene where you can see people in high visibility clothing shouting “GO GO”. This authority figure who is yelling and the unsteadiness of the camera creates a sense of fear. The composition and framing of the police cars driving by mediates to the viewer that there is chaos on the streets of London. The graphical map and serious stern voiceover emphasis consternation of the attack. The use of imagery at the end of the report of disorder on the streets after the incident mediates to the mass population panic and concern. Breckenridge & Zimbardo (2007) state that terrorism mediated by news outlets can play a “critical role in facilitating the psychological processes that intensify the public’s fear and apprehensions (2007, p.116). It is apparent that Sky news present more discourse of fear to their viewers.
At the beginning of the report, the audience is exposed to video footage of two people injured from the incident, captured on a mobile phone presenting to the viewer that this is the reality. At the end of the report, we are presented with an interview from an authority figure, MP Labour Mary Creagh, who reports there was a “sense of panic” and “shooting behind us”. Thus, demonstrating to the viewer the severity of this event. Sky and BBC news present the report as unsympathetic by interviewing witnesses who are still in shock and broadcasting insensitive footage of civilians whilst injured. This discourse of analysis refers to the approach of language and social configuration (Fairclough, 2013). Language that is mediated to us through news platforms is normalised due to acceptance from society. We as a society accept what is socially acceptable as social norms. It is then the viewer’s decision how they perceive the information which is mediated to them. Stuart Hall (1980) explains how a text can differentiate itself from the meaning of it and the intention of it. This purpose of manipulation through language is how the preferred meaning can be communicated to the viewer. However, the viewers decode and encode information through their perception of the news. Fairclough (2013) states that discourse “brings into the complex relations which constitute social life: meaning, and making meaning” (2013, p.3)
The BBC reporters voiceover is stern and serious throughout the report identifying to the audience the context of the report. BBC news introduces the first interviewee as a Danish teenager who explains in his own words the occurrence of the tragic incident. Throughout the interview the report uses subtitles. The male adolescent’s tone of voice conveys a sense grief and distress as the interviewee states “I’m in shock”. The tone of voice delivers to the viewer the weight of the terror attack upon witnesses at the scene. Even though the BBC is an English broadcaster, viewers may not relate and interact with the Danish accent. However, the expression of sorrow mediated to the viewers resonates with the audience and we accept it due to the context of the information. The BBC interview five people in total. Three witnesses, one authority figure and one Dailymail Journalist. Out of the five interviews, four interviewees were foreign people and one national man. The use of a variety of voices may sometimes present the news in a different tone. However, due to the circumstances, we recognise the situation. Sky news portrays the beginning of their report similar to the BBC report by using a serious voice-over setting the scene of the report. Sky news use three interviewees all of whom were English. The mode of discourse presented by both reports is fear through the use of visuals, audio and interviews with witnesses. This constant push of terrorism as the intended meaning to the viewer constructs the reality creating a moral panic. Different news broadcasters present news to different audiences depending on the culture and the country from which the information is broadcast from. Stuart Hall (2013) implies that viewers’ who decode and encode media information form and shape their own preferred meaning. However, the producer’s attempt to shape the viewers’ thoughts without them doing so themselves.
Without a script there is no narrative thus it is not appealing or entertaining to the viewer. The use of live footage and footage captured on a camera portrays the reality of the event capturing the audience’s attention. The composition, editing and delivery of the report creates the narrative. When society fear they turn to authority as a sense of what will happen next. Sky news use Theresa Mays speech identifying an authority figure and a MET Police Acting Deputy Commissioner in the report. BBC use a representative of Foreign Affairs. This use of a representation and authority figure portrays to the audience the serious issue at hand. At the beginning, the Sky news report shows live footage. We can hear the man who has captured the footage speaking about the incident where he announces “terror attack”, subtly communicated the preferred meaning. Additionally, the reporters voiceover begins soon after speaking of how one victim is lying under the wheels of a bus. However, they begin to blur this scene out. Therefore, we can not confirm if this is true or not. Throughout the report, we can identify the increase in audio at specific times throughout the report such as the volume increasing after the gunshots and the sound of ambulances rushing to the aid of victims. Sky news reports about an image that an armed officer “strikes an incongruous figure” although he is only directing people. This fabrication through the use of language used and composition shapes the intended reading to the audience. Sky news reports that tourist were trapped in the London Eye. However, the London Eye itself stops for tourists to take in the view. We are presented with an image of the police standing around the attacker’s body while the reporter reveals that the two circles are where the knives are positioned. However, we can not identify clearly if they are knives. Sky and BBC news compose and edit the report creating it to be engaging with the viewer. The use of visuals and audio is used to maintain the viewers’ attention.
People turn to the media to provide some kind of solace. However, if viewers decode hidden messages from the report of the preferred meaning they would recognise that news broadcasters fabricate stories with the intention of creating fear and further moral panic. Terrorism sells and news outlets will package terror stories until they exhaust the news report.
Within the last few years, people have been turning to different media outlets to obtain news and this information is having an impact on traditional news broadcasters especially commercial broadcasters who rely on the views of the audience (Allan, 2008). Thus, having a negative impact on ratings and viewers for news stations. With the internet offering people a broader choice of news at a faster rate, people are turning to alternatives other than traditional news reports. In addition, Youtube channels inform people of an alternative approach to information. This, in turn, presents viewers with various preferred meanings or neutrality giving the viewer the ability to construct their own reality. In conclusion, the question that remains: Can the news media continue to act as producers of meaning whilst remaining within the structure of formal rules about impartiality? Yes, they can. However, news broadcasters can communicate the preferred meaning through news reports without the audience noticing, even if the audience decode and encode framing their own mediated reality. The mediated context still intends to communicate hidden messages. BBC showed neutrality in their news report however, Sky news reported their report on a terror attack. The construction of the narrative, language and visuals used creates the discourse of fear in a subtle manner. However, I understand there is a thin line between the rules of impartiality and what is mediated to viewers as the preferred meaning.
Reference
Allan, S., 2006. Online news: Journalism and the Internet. McGraw-Hill Education (UK).
Altheide, D.L., 1997. The news media, the problem frame, and the production of fear. The sociological quarterly, 38(4), pp.647-668.
Bbc.co.uk. (2017). BBC – Impartiality: Introduction – Editorial Guidelines. [online] Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/impartiality [Accessed 13 May 2017].
BBC (2017). BBC. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC [Accessed 13 May 2017].
Breckenridge, J.N. and Zimbardo, P.G., 2007. The strategy of terrorism and the psychology of mass-mediated fear. Psychology of terrorism, pp.116-133.
Cushion, S., Lewis, J. and Lang, P. (2010). The Rise of 24-hour News Television: Global Perspectives. 1st ed.
Fairclough, N., 2013. Critical discourse analysis: The critical study of language. Routledge.
Hall, S., 1980. Cultural studies: Two paradigms. Media, Culture & Society, 2(1), pp.57-72.
Ofcom. (2017). Section five: Due impartiality and due accuracy. [online] Available at: https://www.ofcom.org.uk/tv-radio-and-on-demand/broadcast-codes/broadcast-code/section-five-due-impartiality-accuracy [Accessed 13 May 2017].
Sky television plc (2017) in Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_Television_plc (Accessed: 12 May 2017).
Sky news (2017) in Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki Sky_News#Legal_cases (Accessed: 12 May 2017).
Watershed (broadcasting) (2017) in Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watershed_(broadcasting)#United_Kingdom (Accessed: 14 May 2017).
2017 Westminster attack (2017). 2017 Westminster attack. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Westminster_attack [Accessed 13 May 2017].
BBC Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGoEzDeqs2I
Sky Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_KJLqxuYrk
Recent Comments