Search

Grace Deane

Communications Graduate

Genre News

The media play a substantial role in shaping the audiences preferred meaning. News stations are owned by public or private broadcasters. Private broadcasters depend on commercial viewings and ratings thus advertising is how news corporation continue to remain as broadcasters. Public broadcasters serve primarily as public servers. Public broadcasting is funded through the public paying their tv license broadcasting channels that the public wants to view. However, the private sector of broadcast whatever content that the channel wishes to. At certain times throughout the day the consumption of different programs are broadcast for example audiences prefer to watch easily digestable media content in the evening time after a long day.

Through the power of ownership private channels constantly push the intended meaning to its audience. Private broadcasters are owned by news corporations, for example, Sky news is controlled and owned by Rupert Murdoch whos polticial views can be constantly pushed through the news channel (Sky news (2017), 2017).

This consumerism constantly pushing the preferred meaning demonstrates very little confidence on information mediated to us. Media moguls own news corporations. Without knowing hidden messages and intended readings are exposed to the audience without them identifying or decoding the mediated information. Thus, media literacy on decoding of news mediated to its viewers is extremily important and is essential in the development of non-biased news stations.

Reference

Sky news (2017) in Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki Sky_News#Legal_cases (Accessed: 17 May 2017).

Media Discourse Analysis Essay

News media outlets have become a platform where society sources information. This information is mediated to us through text, video and imagery. News reports mediate information to their viewers through preferred meaning. Every text that has been mediated to us is decoded, constructed and delivered as an intended message. This preferred meaning has an effect on how society shapes their opinion on topics of discussion. The perception of what we choose to believe from the information that is given creates the reality. However, it is the viewers’ choice whether they decide to engage with the news or not. In this essay, I will discuss an analytical comparison of the news report on the Westminster attack that occurred on March 22, 2017. Within this analysis, I am required to source the news report from two news broadcasters within the same jurisdiction, one from a commercial broadcaster and one from a Public Service Broadcaster. I must refer to theories that we studied within this semester while focusing on the question at hand; Can the news media continue to act as producers of meaning whilst remaining within the structure of formal rules about impartiality?. 

This comparative analysis investigates how Sky news and BBC News create media content while remaining under the accord of the 2009 Broadcasting Act with regard to impartiality. The Broadcasting Authority of the United Kingdom Ofcom Broadcasting Code reports that “News, in whatever form, must be reported with due accuracy and presented with due impartiality” (Ofcom, 2017). Sky and BBC News operate under United Kingdom broadcasting regulations (Sky news, 2017) (Bbc.co.uk, 2017). Following, Watershed regulations BBC and Sky news reports were reported between the hours of  21:00-5:30 due to the explicit footage (Watershed (broadcasting), 2017).

On the 22nd of March, 2017 an attack occurred in the Palace of Westminster Abbey in London. It was reported that four people were fatally injured, whilst 46 people were injured. While news outlets reported it was a terrorist attack it was later confirmed by police that no link was associated with the attacker and a terrorist organisation (2017 Westminster attack, 2017). While the BBC is a public broadcaster and Sky news is a commercial broadcaster, both news stations deliver the news in a very different manner. As BBC news is funded by the British Government and Sky news is a private limited company (Sky news, 2017) (BBC,2017). Sky news is much more dependable on grabbing the audiences’ attention by reporting sooner on news reports relying on ratings and views. However, Sky facts which are reported may not always be confirmed prior to the report (Cushion, Lewis and Lang, 2010). This inaccuracy that is reported to the viewer demonstrates the broadcasters intention of the preferred meaning without confirming references first. While both news outlets reported on the same report I was quite surprised how BBC reported the incident. The use of the first witness still in shock from the scene perceived BBC as insensitive with the reporter asking “how many bodies did you see” to the Danish student.

Boorstin (1961) states that reports by news outlets can be categorised into three events. These include Genuine Events, Media Events and Pseudo-Events. The Westminster attack is classified as a Genuine event as it occurred without the production of the media. However, this event became a mediated event through the construction of reality. The use of live and recorded footage placed in the report gives viewers the illusion of what is reality. The created fabrication of this Genuine event formed into a media event holds the viewers’ attention for the purpose of entertainment. This information which is mediated to us is second-hand information. Only witnesses who witnessed the scene obtain first-hand information. Sky news re-presentation of the information is that this attack was an attack on terrorism. The use of the sidebar coming across the screen displaying “Terror Attack” identifies the preferred meaning which Sky news communicates to its audience. However, BBC does not indicate a bias throughout the report. Although, during one of the interviews with Ismail, the reporter questions the Ismail about the identification of the driver trying to construct the viewer’s thoughts that it was a terrorist attack asking “Did you get a chance to see the gentleman driving the car”. This perception of what we believe from the information that is given creates the reality. Certain news may be seen to some viewers as informative and to others as fear mongering. Information becomes more newsworthy when it affects people.

As the discourse of fear pervades everyday life, more experiences seem to be captured by it.     Audiences then become more likely to be included as corroborating witnesses to give testimony compatible with the themes resonating the discourse of fear (Altheide, 1997, p. 19).

This report is based on fear. The opening scene of the BBC report displays live footage of civilians running in panic while the background audio plays several screams and gunshots. The intention of the beginning of this report captures the viewers’ attention combining with the increase in the audio volume with the screams and sounds of gun shots. Following the next scene where you can see people in high visibility clothing shouting “GO GO”. This authority figure who is yelling and the unsteadiness of the camera creates a sense of fear. The composition and framing of the police cars driving by mediates to the viewer that there is chaos on the streets of London. The graphical map and serious stern voiceover emphasis consternation of the attack. The use of imagery at the end of the report of disorder on the streets after the incident mediates to the mass population panic and concern. Breckenridge & Zimbardo (2007) state that terrorism mediated by news outlets can play a “critical role in facilitating the psychological processes that intensify the public’s fear and apprehensions (2007, p.116). It is apparent that Sky news present more discourse of fear to their viewers.

At the beginning of the report, the audience is exposed to video footage of two people injured from the incident, captured on a mobile phone presenting to the viewer that this is the reality. At the end of  the report, we are presented with an interview from an authority figure, MP Labour Mary Creagh, who reports there was a “sense of panic” and “shooting behind us”. Thus, demonstrating to the viewer the severity of this event. Sky and BBC news present the report as unsympathetic by interviewing witnesses who are still in shock and broadcasting insensitive footage of civilians whilst injured. This discourse of analysis refers to the approach of language and social configuration (Fairclough, 2013). Language that is mediated to us through news platforms is normalised due to acceptance from society. We as a society accept what is socially acceptable as social norms. It is then the viewer’s decision how they perceive the information which is mediated to them. Stuart Hall (1980) explains how a text can differentiate itself from the meaning of it and the intention of it. This purpose of manipulation through language is how the preferred meaning can be communicated to the viewer. However, the viewers decode and encode information through their perception of the news. Fairclough (2013) states that discourse “brings into the complex relations which constitute social life: meaning, and making meaning” (2013, p.3)

The BBC reporters voiceover is stern and serious throughout the report identifying to the audience the context of the report. BBC news introduces the first interviewee as a Danish teenager who explains in his own words the occurrence of the tragic incident. Throughout the interview the report uses subtitles. The male adolescent’s tone of voice conveys a sense grief and distress as the interviewee states “I’m in shock”. The tone of voice delivers to the viewer the weight of the terror attack upon witnesses at the scene. Even though the BBC is an English broadcaster, viewers may not relate and interact with the Danish accent. However, the expression of sorrow mediated to the viewers resonates with the audience and we accept it due to the context of the information. The BBC interview five people in total. Three witnesses, one authority figure and one Dailymail Journalist. Out of the five interviews, four interviewees were foreign people and one national man. The use of a variety of voices may sometimes present the news in a different tone. However, due to the circumstances, we recognise the situation. Sky news portrays the beginning of their report similar to the BBC report by using a serious voice-over setting the scene of the report. Sky news use three interviewees all of whom were English. The mode of discourse presented by both reports is fear through the use of visuals, audio and interviews with witnesses. This constant push of terrorism as the intended meaning to the viewer constructs the reality creating a moral panic. Different news broadcasters present news to different audiences depending on the culture and the country from which the information is broadcast from. Stuart Hall (2013) implies that viewers’ who decode and encode media information form and shape their own preferred meaning. However, the producer’s attempt to shape the viewers’ thoughts without them doing so themselves.

Without a script there is no narrative thus it is not appealing or entertaining to the viewer. The use of live footage and footage captured on a camera portrays the reality of the event capturing the audience’s attention. The composition, editing and delivery of the report creates the narrative. When society fear they turn to authority as a sense of what will happen next. Sky news use Theresa Mays speech identifying an authority figure and a MET Police Acting Deputy Commissioner in the report. BBC use a representative of Foreign Affairs. This use of a representation and authority figure portrays to the audience the serious issue at hand. At the beginning, the Sky news report shows live footage. We can hear the man who has captured the footage speaking about the incident where he announces “terror attack”, subtly communicated the preferred meaning. Additionally, the reporters voiceover begins soon after speaking of how one victim is lying under the wheels of a bus. However, they begin to blur this scene out. Therefore, we can not confirm if this is true or not. Throughout the report, we can identify the increase in audio at specific times throughout the report such as the volume increasing after the gunshots and the sound of ambulances rushing to the aid  of victims. Sky news reports about an image that an armed officer “strikes an incongruous figure” although he is only directing people. This fabrication through the use of language used and composition shapes the intended reading to the audience. Sky news reports that tourist were trapped in the London Eye. However, the London Eye itself stops for tourists to take in the view. We are  presented with an image of the police standing around the attacker’s body while the reporter reveals that the two circles are where the knives are positioned. However, we can not identify clearly if they are knives. Sky and BBC news compose and edit the report creating it to be engaging with the viewer. The use of visuals and audio is used to maintain the viewers’ attention.

People turn to the media to provide some kind of solace. However, if viewers decode hidden messages from the report of the preferred meaning they would recognise that news broadcasters fabricate stories with the intention of creating fear and further moral panic. Terrorism sells and news outlets will package terror stories until they exhaust the news report.

Within the last few years, people have been turning to different media outlets to obtain news and this information is having an impact on traditional news broadcasters especially commercial broadcasters who rely on the views of the audience (Allan, 2008). Thus, having a negative impact on ratings and viewers for news stations. With the internet offering people a broader choice of news at a faster rate, people are turning to alternatives other than traditional news reports. In addition, Youtube channels inform people of an alternative approach to information. This, in turn, presents viewers with various preferred meanings or neutrality giving the viewer the ability to construct their own reality. In conclusion, the question that remains: Can the news media continue to act as producers of meaning whilst remaining within the structure of formal rules about impartiality? Yes, they can. However, news broadcasters can communicate the preferred meaning through news reports without the audience noticing, even if the audience decode and encode framing their own mediated reality. The mediated context still intends to communicate hidden messages. BBC showed neutrality in their news report however, Sky news reported their report on a terror attack. The construction of the narrative, language and visuals used creates the discourse of fear in a subtle manner. However, I understand there is a thin line between the rules of impartiality and what is mediated to viewers as the preferred meaning.

Reference

Allan, S., 2006. Online news: Journalism and the Internet. McGraw-Hill Education (UK).

Altheide, D.L., 1997. The news media, the problem frame, and the production of fear. The sociological quarterly, 38(4), pp.647-668.

Bbc.co.uk. (2017). BBC – Impartiality: Introduction – Editorial Guidelines. [online] Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/impartiality [Accessed 13 May 2017].

BBC (2017). BBC. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC [Accessed 13 May 2017].

Breckenridge, J.N. and Zimbardo, P.G., 2007. The strategy of terrorism and the psychology of mass-mediated fear. Psychology of terrorism, pp.116-133.

Cushion, S., Lewis, J. and Lang, P. (2010). The Rise of 24-hour News Television: Global Perspectives. 1st ed.

Fairclough, N., 2013. Critical discourse analysis: The critical study of language. Routledge.

Hall, S., 1980. Cultural studies: Two paradigms. Media, Culture & Society, 2(1), pp.57-72.

Ofcom. (2017). Section five: Due impartiality and due accuracy. [online] Available at: https://www.ofcom.org.uk/tv-radio-and-on-demand/broadcast-codes/broadcast-code/section-five-due-impartiality-accuracy [Accessed 13 May 2017].

Sky television plc (2017) in Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_Television_plc (Accessed: 12 May 2017).

Sky news (2017) in Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki Sky_News#Legal_cases (Accessed: 12 May 2017).

Watershed (broadcasting) (2017) in Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watershed_(broadcasting)#United_Kingdom (Accessed: 14 May 2017).

2017 Westminster attack (2017). 2017 Westminster attack. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Westminster_attack [Accessed 13 May 2017].

BBC Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGoEzDeqs2I

Sky Link:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_KJLqxuYrk

Ownership & Means of Production

When questions need to be answered many people looked to institutions especially religiousestablishments for responses. However, these institutions that used to provide meaning for people no longer have a place for people in modern contemporary day society. Recently, people have begun to turn to other organisations for answers such as media outlets. In today’s society, people turn to the media to provide some kind of solace. Additionally, people would have turned to an authority for answers and help. However, due to media exposure on police brutality. People have become more reluctant to search for meaning through the police. This demand for meaning from humans also has further need to understand their identity. People hang onto this form of identity thus this shaping affects the meaning. The omission of this identity can have an effect on people.

As a result, the media has established this form of power. Media content is delivered, edited and packaged for a meaning to society. Marxists approach suggests Hegemony refers to a hierarchy of leadership and dominance. As the media has created this power it can produce content in a way that society will form their own ideas and beliefs. However, we must understand that the media does not reflect what society is collectively. The media has neo-liberalist views, for example, the portrayal of protests resulting in violent acts of terror. In addition, Marxist refers to Ideology through the media. News stations influence how society can question and consider a topic thus affecting their views on issues. Marxists indicated that due to power and wealth news corporations can filter out information before it is broadcasted or delivered to print. The hierarchy of domineering interest decides what information is broadcasted to the public. This essentially is the propaganda model as it filters news. The mass media has five filters of the propaganda news model these include

  1. Media Ownership
  2. Advertising
  3. News Shapes
  4. News Makers
  5. Pressure Groups

These five filters edit, create and shape what information is newsworthy.

The public denies alternative news which supports Marxists approach. As news stations do not report alternative news or facts this, in turn, is why society as a whole does not this type of information. We begin to see buzz words of 2017 being ‘Alternative Facts’ or ‘Fake News’. With this many late night talk shows have taken this advantage and used it as segments.

While media can be biased due to the hierarchy of power and wealth it is still our decision whether we engage with information or not. However, while this is true if you are constantly bombarded with the same news edited and packaged it is hard to difference between news and the truth.

Narrative and Stories

 

We are exposed to news stories every day given to us through different forms of news outlets. These different outlets include photography, illustrations, video footage and quotes. If masses of news stations broadcasted unedited first-hand information nearly all news would become uninteresting. Our news is edited and packaged in a way creating the information to become more engaging and palliative for the viewers. We become more engrossed with news when it affects us personally and when the story has a narrative.

Live footage captures and holds viewers attention as it is happening in real time. The use of composition and editing of footage creates a narrative thus maintaining the viewer’s attention. The narration that drives the story also has to be driven from the script. Furthermore, news stories will interview an authority figure portraying to the audience that the information given is a serious issue. Additionally, a representative from the catholic church would be used in the report. However, since exposure to recent events that have occurred by the catholic church. There is less exposure of interviews from the catholic church as fewer people are seeking answers from their religion. The editing of charts displays the severity or epidemic of the subject creating more engagement. How the story is framed affects how people engage with it. The re-presentation of information is fabricated and molded in a way that is more entertaining. The use of photography shots while a voice-over of the reporter is used in news reports again creating a serious note on the report.

If the information has no narrative then the story is less entertaining. Some news reports will use the story until it is over-used and exhausted. Every news report is edited in a way that is more entertaining to the audience. However, if all news reports are edited and packaged in a way, what really is the difference between the truth and reality.

Advertising Image of Women

Women’s bodies are sexually objectified through the media especially through print advertisement. We are exposed up to 2,000 advertisements a day (SJ Insights, LLC, 2017). This can have an effect on how women perceive their own bodies. Women’s bodies are portrayed in western culture as tall slender bodies. Additionally, men’s bodies are seen as tall muscular bodies in the western world. However, in different cultures, we see a dynamic change in body shapes. This is due to what is mediated to us through advertisements. Advertisements are seen as a reflection of our society. However, applications such as Instagram and Snapchat have altered the way in which women think about their body as they are exposed to many more body shapes through social media.

As we are exposed up to 2,000 advertisements every day this can have a psychological effect on our perception of our own bodies and the bodies of others. We subconsciously process advertisements. This then has an effect on our cognitive process in relation to our bodies thus can have an effect on women’s body dissatisfaction and internalization of body standards.

This advertisement is for menswear, however, the use of the women’s bodies as an object is still being utilized in a clothing advert for men. This advert is used for western society.  The ideological concept behind this advertisement is that the man is in charge standing over the women, who is seen has an object being viewed in her slender form.

ad

Tom Ford are notorious for the sexually objectifying women’s and the dismemberment of body shapes through the media.

f

 

Reference 

SJ Insights, LLC. (2017). New Research Sheds Light on Daily Ad Exposures. [online] Available at: https://sjinsights.net/2014/09/29/new-research-sheds-light-on-daily-ad-exposures/ [Accessed 20 Apr. 2017].

Semiotics – Revisted

Semiotics is based on how the meaning of a sign or symbol is communicated and interpreted by who it is mediated to, the receiver. Pierce theory of signs declares that “a sign is not a sign unless it is interpreted as a sign” (Pierce, 1902). These signs can take the form of text, images and audio.

Ferdinand de Saussure explored how the sign is a two-part model. He described a sign as (Culler, 1986)

a signifier – the form which the sign takes

the signified – the concept it represents

 

The term signifier and signified both collectively function together when talking about an object. One cannot work without the other. However, Barthes explores this theory further. Suggesting that there can be three forms of the same meaning. The first meaning is denotation, meaning the idea of what the word suggests to the receiver. The perception of the meaning dog can be different from one person to another. This being the primary level of signification. The connotation of the signifier is the canine creature this is described as the signifier of secondary signification. Nevertheless, Barthes explains that there is further existence of the meaning. The use of the word dog can also be described by a person, “she’s a dog”. This being a derogatory term used to portray someone. This is the third order of signification producing ideology. The semiotic structure is another way of communicating the desired message to the consumer through the use of advertisement. Furthermore, text that is mediated to us can have associations with paradigms.

A semiotic structure is another way of communicating the desired message to the consumer. This can beaccomplished through the use of advertisement. Furthermore, text or adverts that are mediated to us can have associations with paradigms.

We engage with signs and objects every day. However, we must acknowledge that a sign has no meaning if we do not engage with it.

Bibiography

Culler, J.D., 1986. Ferdinand de Saussure. Cornell University Press.

Peirce, C.S., 1902. Logic as semiotic: The theory of signs.

 

Semiotics

We are constantly bombarded with advertisements every day. The human eye is exposed to over 2,000 (SJ Insights, LLC, 2017) adverts a day.  This, in turn, can have an effect on how women perceive themselves and others. Women’s bodies are sexually objectified through the media especially print advertisements. Sex sells and this is advertisements agencies use this to their advantage when marketing advertisements. Girls who are exposed to advertisements which sexually objectify the female body can have an internal effect on their body standards which in turn can have psychological effects.

I will discuss Carl’s JR a fast food company that advertised their burger analysing this print advertisement in relation to semiotics.

paris hilton.jpg

Types of Signifiers 

Pierce (Peirce,1902) theory discusses the three forms of signs:

Icon

The icon is the image itself. The depiction of the women holding the burger has connotations associated with the phrase, this is the concept of the event.

Index

The representation of the image is the women holding the burger while her body is being objectified. Furthermore, the composition of the body and the burger are associated with the quotation.

Symbol

The symbol of this advertisement is that the bigger the burger the better. However, it is also associated to sexual reference. However, without the advertisement of the burger consumers may associate this image with page 3 newspapers.

Paradigmatic Relationship 

The paradigmatic relationship in this image begins with the use of the burger and the association of the phrase emphasising the sexual content of the advertisement. The use of the black car in the background creates a more seductive ambience. Furthermore, the model’s hair swept back gives us fewer distractions thereby enabling the viewer to focus on the body as an object. The focus is intended to be on the product which is the burger, however, the body is emphasised more even though there are two images of the product. Additionally, the advert is signifying that fast food is more appealing than the women’s body.

Syntagmatic related signs 

The associate with the language and sexual references is driven by the sexual objectification of the woman’s body. The quote used “She’ll tell you size doesn’t matter. She’s lying” is in reference to the burgers connotation.

However, there is a sexual innuendo towards the size of a male’s manhood. Furthermore, the quote indicating “It’s going to get messy” has another sexual reference. This advert is advertised for western society. This advert would not be accepted in the United Arab Emirates. The different cultural values can depend on what is legally permitted to be advertised in what country.

Narratives and Myths within our culture

The narrative of this advert is the advertising of the product portraying the burger to be palatable for the viewers. The advertisement illustrates to the viewer that the burger is more desirable than the woman’s body. This advertisement for Carl’s Jr presents that within our western culture the size of a portion of food matters. The connotations associated with this advert is the size of a male’s manhood.

A campaign launched against Carls Jr called “CUTTHECARLS” demanding the company end their sexist commercials which sexually objectify women’s bodies.

Screen Shot 2017-04-24 at 6.40.00 p.m..png  Screen Shot 2017-04-24 at 6.39.13 p.m..png

Women’s bodies are objectified every day through various media outlets. When women’s bodies are used as a mere object no one wins. As a society, we must not feed into the buying and consuming of these adverts that sexually objectify women’s bodies.

Reference

Fashionbi.com. (2017). Controversial Fashion Campaigns – How far is too far?. [online] Available at: https://fashionbi.com/newspaper/controversial-fashion-campaigns-how-far-is-too-far [Accessed 13 Apr. 2017].

SJ Insights, LLC. (2017). New Research Sheds Light on Daily Ad Exposures. [online] Available at: https://sjinsights.net/2014/09/29/new-research-sheds-light-on-daily-ad-exposures/ [Accessed 13 Apr. 2017].

Peirce, C.S., 1902. Logic as semiotic: The theory of signs.

Conversational Analysis

A message that we receive is encoded and then decoded to the preferred meaning. How we shape the preferred meaning is how we then engage with the message. The use of accents delivers to the audience a better understanding of the topic at hand, this is called the fluency effect. When the message is mediated in an accent that we can relate to we begin to interact and decode the information. Media applies different languages that are appropriate for the context of the information.

Emmet Kirwan tells the story of the challenges a young teenage mother from Dublin faces. The use of Emmet Kirwan and his inner city Dublin voices correlates with the story as it is based in Dublin. This story mediated to the audience is reflective of the language. This is an example of how the preferred language is applied to a piece of media context

John Heritege (1985) formulation is designed for the interviewer to manage the interview within the limitations. Formulation is used for informing the audience of the understanding of the conversation. In addition, formulation is used for the interviewee to receive the information he or she requires from the interview. An information guide would be used as a tool to assist the interview.

David Greatbach (1986) suggests that violation is used in an interview when the question has not been answered by the interviewee. This violation can have an effect on the interviewee outside of the discussion.

I will begin to deconstruct and analysis Jeremy Paxman’s interview with Michael Howard in 1997. I will ask myself several questions we discussed in tutorial class decoding the interview.

Is the interviewer maintaining a stance of ‘formal neutrality’? Or can we see some form of bias?

At the beginning, Paxman approaches this interview with Howard in a serious tone. Paxman does not build a rapport as he asks Micheal serious questions in a direct manner. During the beginning of the interview, Jeremy gives Micheal a chance to explain his side of the story. However, we then begin to see a form of bias with Howard asking the question thirteen times, Did you threaten to over-rule him? Referring to political misconduct by Howard.

In addition, Paxman uses the Dailymail as a source which any journalist would know that is not a reliable source.

How are the questions being answered by the interviewee? (regarding language being used, is it conversational?)

We can identify that Howard has beeing media trained. Micheal knew exactly what kind of questions would arise in this interview. However, I do not think Howard would have thought Paxman would have asked the same question thirteen times. Howard did not give Paxman the answer he wanted thus demonstrating the stance Micheal kept.

Has the interviewee answered the specific question that has been asked?

Micheal Howard did not ask the specific question that had been asked. If Micheal had answered yes to the question he would have lost his position as a politician. However, if he had answered no he would have been branded a liar. Howard answered around the question.

What approach is the interviewee using, if any, to avoid providing an answer to a specific question?

Formulation is used to guide the interview the way Paxman intends for it to go. However, Howard states that “I was entitled to be consulted”, not answering the direct question Paxman had asked.

Is the interviewer allowing this to happen (violation) or are they pushing for an answer to a question?

The interviewer is pushing for the answer but not in violation as Paxman just wants a yes or no answer from the over-rule question. As he states “It’s a straight yes or no answer, Did you threaten to over-rule him?”

Can we see the use of language within the interview being influenced by the perceived social context of the ‘target audience’?

Paxman’s interrogative language within this interview identifies that the target audience of viewers are already politically informed. In addition, Paxman does not have to dissect the discussion to his audience.

To conclude I think Paxman journalistic approach caught Howard off guard. Nevertheless, Howard could not have answered the question that was given to him. As Howard knew the consequences, he would endure on his career. However, if Paxman had got Howard to answer the question with a yes or no answer, it would have been successful in the history of Paxman’s journalism career.

What is Media Discourse?

What is media discourse? How does media discourse interact with the receiver? Media discourse refers to how context is mediated through broadcast or social media platform, this can be verbal or written. Furthermore, media discourse is anything further than a sentence, it is thought out and structured for the viewer.

Discourse Analysis refers to a language of former social practice (Fairclough, 2013). This language that we perceive to be normalised is due to it being mediated to us through the mass media in which society has accepted it as a social norm. Stuart Hall (1980) refers to what a text will actually act from to what it actually means. We decide collectively what is seen as normal in society from how we perceive the information given to us. This use of language from the media has an impact on how we decode and encode information. Mass Media can be structured and presented for different types of audiences. These audiences may include people of different culture, nationality or language. Stuart Hall states that viewers who encode and decode media text shape their preferred meaning may. However, their meaning may not be identical to producers of the context. Additionally, this is difficult for the producers to create a preferred meaning for both people within and outside the text.

Binary opposites have been created through the media of Us and Them, the good and bad. These binary opposites are used to organise a story through the media. The media creates these narratives reinforcing them. However, we must recognise that we play a role in consuming this news. Broadcasters produce content of several discourses. However, the prime discourse that people attain further attention is the discourse of fear. Broadcasters create fear from the headline of the story to the audio played in the report. RTE created the discourse of fear from the Regency Hotel shootings that occurred last year. Then reinforcing this terror through the late late show with special guest Paul Williams speaking about how dangerous these gangland crimes are. Additionally, binary opposites are applied in this story using Them as the Gangland crime and Us as the people. Paul Williams has published several books relating to gangland crime in Ireland. The titles of his books use connotations relating to the meaning.

Media discourse is surrounded by all text we contain. This type of discourse analysis is a method used to analyse the text. Advertisements have a clear connection to the rhetorical nature of the text thus the use of Discourse analysis is beneficial when people are decoding adverts. These type of themes and ideas that we precede in the actual language are used so that we understand the discourses that have been accepted through social norms.

bk-ad

paul

 

 

Reference

Fairclough, N., 2013. Critical discourse analysis: The critical study of language. Routledge.

Hall, S., 1980. Cultural studies: Two paradigms. Media, Culture & Society, 2(1), pp.57-72.

Anon, 2015. Robot Check. Robot Check. Available at: https://www.amazon.com/Murder-Inc-Irelands-Dangerous-Criminal/dp/0241970466 [Accessed March 21, 2017].

What is Newsworthy?

How does news become newsworthy? Is first-hand information newsworthy or does it always have to be constructed and mediated to its audience for people receive and engage with it? I will examine the five key considerations that are necessary for us to decode news that is presented to its viewers. In addition, I will be applying the five key considerations and Galtung and Ruge (1965) news value list to the report by RTE of Dublin’s Icy Footpath during 2010.

There are the five questions I will examine when decoding the report:

  1. Who created this message?
  2.  What creative techniques are used to attract my attention?
  3. How might different people understand this message differently from me?
  4. What lifestyles, values and points of view are represented in, or omitted from, this message?
  5. Why was this message sent?  (Benjamin,2007)

Who created this message?

Every text that has been mediated to us is decoded, constructed and delivered. These choices of how to portray the story, language to apply and what imagery or footage to use are all created for the purpose of our entertainment. The message was created by RTE, the national public broadcaster of Ireland. The information was provided informing people to be cautious while walking on icy footpaths.

What creative techniques are used to attract my attention?

Editorial Newspapers, Radio and Television Stations all edit and construct information to create news of value. This piece of news that was edited together creatively had an ideal link to what one of the interviewees was explaining about the slippery pathways and broken bones before showing someone slip on the street.

How might different people understand this message differently from me?

Information is given to us. However, how we understand and create our own meaning of the news is different from one person to the next. Certain people may perceive this news to be informative giving caution to people who may decide to walk on icy pathways. Additionally, some may find this piece of news amusing as they see a person has fallen, as there were skits and parodies of this story surfacing youtube and facebook.

What lifestyles, values and points of view are represented in, or omitted from, this message? 

The use of the sidebar at the bottom of the screen informing people to be careful walking. Furthermore, have information that was reported by the Garda for people in Tramore not to be walking on frozen lakes.

Why was this message sent?

This message was reported to viewers informing them of the dangers of walking and driving on slippery streets and roads. The use of footage of the man falling also gained further coverage than just RTE shaping the information to be newsworthy. The message was also broadcasted to the audience at the Six o’clock news which is prime news time.

When decoding information we should also consider Galtung and Ruge (1996) news values. I will identify how these principles apply to this news report.

  1. Extrodinaries: Was the story expected or unexpected?
  2. Threshold: Was there a lot of media attention around the story at the time?
  3. Unambiguity: Was the story easy for people to understand and engage with?
  4. Reference to an Elite persons: Were there celebrities or people of authority or power involved in the news event?
  5. Reference to an Elite nations: Did the report include people of similar culture and nationality?
  6. Personalisation: The involvement of people from the community or whom people may know on a personal level contributes to the newsworthiness of the story.
  7. Frequency: Is there a time limit on how worthy the news is?
  8. Narrative: Does the report narrate a story?
  9. Negative: Is the story negative? Negative news always holds onto people’s attention for longer.
  10. Fear Based: Does the story convey fear to its audience?

 

Now I will apply Galtung and Ruge news value list to the news reported by RTE

  1. Extrodinaries: The story was expected in the sense that people knew about the treacherous weather. However, the man falling was unexpected for viewers
  2. Threshold: There were several youtube channels and facebook pages discussing the man falling. In addition, creating parodies and skits of the event.
  3. Unambiguity: The man falling made the story easier for people to comprehend what the story was actually about.
  4. Reference to an Elite persons: The use of the favourable reporter Brian Dobson was an additional factor to the newsworthiness of the story.
  5. Reference to an Elite nations: The reporters were both Irish. However, one interviewee was Irish and one was a tourist.
  6. Personalisation: The voice of three Irish people contributing to the report constructs the information on a more personal level.
  7. Frequency: As the weather improved this information had a time limit. Although, the humour of the footage expanded over a longer period of time.
  8. Narrative: The flow of the story is provided from the report.
  9. Negative: The story is seen in a negative light in the sense that people have fallen and weather conditions are hazardous. Nevertheless, it also has a positive aspect to it as salts are being spread on the streets.
  10. Fear Based: This report creates fear that people will hurt themselves

Newsworthy is information of a necessity but what really is valuable information in people’s lives. The value of news has developed over the years. What is seen as newsworthy now may not have been as valuable ten years ago. The news is constructed and presented and packaged to us only to be decoded again to what we decide to engage with.

Reference

Benjamin N. Cardozo High School. 2007. 5 Questions 5 Concepts Media Lit. [ONLINE] Available at:http://cardozohigh.enschool.org/ourpages/auto/2011/3/2/52738988/5%20Questions%205%20Concepts%20Media%20Lit%202007.pdf. [Accessed 20 March 2017].

Johan Galtung and Mari Holmboe Ruge, 1965. “The structure of foreign news: The presentation of the Congo, Cuba and Cyprus crises in four Norwegian newspapers,” Journal of Peace Research, volume 2, number 1, pp. 64–90.[Accessed 20 February 2015]

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free